I've tried to make some minimoog-style substractive synth, don't expect anything to sound really close to the original so I called it the "miniwoog". Pd-extended is required, I added an arpeggiator, a basic sequencer and some effects. I've included some presets for a quick overview, hope someone will find this whole thing useful or fun to play with.

Maelstorm's bandlimited oscillators are indeed doing a very good job. Here is the original thread where he explained his method :

http://forum.pdpatchrepo.info/topic/4048/bandlimited-oscillators

This is the best anti-aliasing method I have seen so far, quite less cpu-hungry than the upsampling path. But still I feel that these oscillators, at least in my patch, are not sounding as they should at high frequencies. Maybe I should blame the filtering method ?

One thing from the original minimoog I've left behind is the ability of the third oscillator to self-modulate. This kind of feedback is hard to get working in pd, I've chose to ignore it rather than getting weird results that would make this oscillator unusable when using frequency modulation.

And as mentionned in the readme file, give me no credit for the effects, I just borrowed them from the rjdj library, which is full of amazing stuff, all of them vanilla-esque if I remember correctly. I've just add a light vibrato in the delay effect, maybe a silly attempt to simulate a slightly defective analog tape delay.

Finally, yep, the miniwoog is free as pd is, as long as you promise me to never set the volume under 90%

[pd asshole] ... I don't know why, but I love it. Nice work!

great work. very fun to play around with. Is the rjdj pd library still online somewhere? abck in the day i had it but ive lost track of it and now i dont see an official download anywhere.

Hey, you can find the rjdj lib here : https://github.com/rjdj/rjlib

Thanks!

really nice, good job!

I am thoroughly impressed. It sounds so good! This should be fun to mess around with.

@coloscope
added to the patch repository, hope you are ok with it (let me know if not). including samples (sadly I didn't have a keyboard).

http://pdpatchrepo.info/patches/patch/153

Hey that's very cool , thank you ! I didn't even knew about the patch repository, it would be nice if more people would add their work there, really inspiring.

I'm currently working on a new version with a lot of improvements (polyphony, modulation matrix, etc) and many new (and hopefully better) presets, I will post here as soon as it's clean and ready.

Fantastic job, this is a really nice synth!

I'd like to try this patch out. But I just installed Pd ver. 0.49.1 from source and it does not work. I think that's because it needs some "externals" that were included with Pd-Extendended. And Pd-extended does not exist any more...

Can anybody help me out?

@MeneerJansen Pd extended still exists....... http://puredata.info/downloads/pd-extended
If you are using windows you can get the zip portable (run anywhere) and use it alongside 0.49.
Extended probably will not run on the latest 64-bit only OSX for Macs.

You can get the externals for Vanilla through the Pd top menu...... "help" ... "Find Externals" but it is possible that some of the ones you need have never been recompiled for 64-bit.
If you can install a 32-bit vanilla that would help if that is the case.

In windows many versions of Pd can be run by clicking "pd.exe" in the bin folder. I have all of them in folders on my desktop for testing purposes. I don't know if that is possible in other OS's.

If you cannot find the externals you need then post back here because sometimes alternative abstractions are available.
David.

@whale-av Thanks for your tips. I use Linux and via the link you posted I can install Pd-extended for very, very old versions of Linux Mint (which is the distro that I use). And I want to use Pd on my Raspberry Pi too, so I'd rather be "future-proof" and try to get it working in Pd Vannilla w/ some externals.

Problem is that I do not know what externals this patch uses. So I do not know what to download in Pd via the menu: "Help --> Find externals". I've tried to install some externals, but you must not search the name of the "object" but the name of its developer!

Example: say you want the Filter "lowpass 2.4.6.8.order with freq and Q signal inlets" made by iemlib (see this link). Then in the 'Find Externals' window you must type in iemlib. Not filter or lowpass.

Another problem is that I might not be using this patch right. I load it in Pd, activate an oscillator by placing a cross next to "on" and raise the volome of the osc and the master volume. I connect a Midi keyboard to my PC, connect it to Pd via qjackctl and play some notes. Nothing happens and I do not see any errors in Pd's console...

@MeneerJansen Hmm... If you load it in 0.49 then you will see in the Terminal (in red) all the objects that could not be created when you open the patch.
Make a list so you can then try to find them.
You could download extended and not install it. You can then search that downloaded folder for the missing objects, to find the names (always the folder name and almost always a subfolder of the "extra" folder) of the libraries that you will need.....

Nothing working........
Any object missing (not created) could stop it working.
Open the top menu "Media".... "Test audio and Midi".....
Is anything going on?
Do you have DSP........ Audio turned on?
David.

@whale-av Tried to copy all the externals from ye 'olde source code from Pd-extended to my own installation dir of Pd. That got rid of some errors. But some errors about " | " stayed. That's strange because that's a Vanilla logical operator.

Then I tried to compile ye 'olde source code from Pd-extended from source code. Got some error about pthread_create@@GLIBC Maybe because pthread does not work anymore in modern C compilers? The current source code compiled without problems on my PC.

Anyway, I was about to give up and then I tried to install an old Linux Mint package (i.e. pre-compiled software). This luckily installed just fine. And guess what? The Moog patch works excellent.

There is a downside to all this, however. It's a shame that de kind developers of Pd make a version that does not work w/ our beloved patches anymore. Not even when you use the 'Find Externals' utility. And not even when you copy all the old Pd-extended externals to your current externals directory. A shame that ll that work on great patches from a few years ago go to waste.

Does anybody know how to compile the old Pd-extended on a mdern Linux system?

Now for that Pd-extended on a Raspberry Pi....

I see that my version of Linux Mint (17.1 "Rebecca") is very, very old. Mint 17 is based on Ubuntu 14. That's why the old Pd-extended package still worked.

Ubuntu versions from 16 on do not have the old library version called libgsl0ldbl (link). So in the future Pd-extended will not work in Linux.

Then there is Purrdata (a fork of Pd-l2Ork which is a fork of Pd-extended). It's executable is, strangely enough, still called Pd-l2Ork. That one still loads this Moog patch. However, the "on screen" keyboard does not work, neither can you load the presets.

I give up on Puredata. Might give running the Pd-extended Windows version in Wine a go (edit: doesn't work. needs a .bat file that doesn't work). But even that ends someday. Shame that all the forks break some sort of backwards compatibility.

@MeneerJansen I didn't manage to get extended to work on a RPI3 (64-bit only) and had to go with vanilla. Extended was fine on the RPI2b.
You know a lot more about compiling though...... if you succeed there will be a lot of people interested.
Yes, the change to Vanilla and then 64-bit has been traumatic. Some developers have updated their libraries, but as you say there is a lot of excellent work gone in the bin.
Some of those libraries were published on github with their source code, and you might have some luck compiling if you can find updated dependencies and match them as well.

Ps. Many of the extended objects work because they are actually abstractions..... so 32/64 is irrelevant.
David.

Hello! Trying to get this working and installed PD-Extended using the Windows installer here. However, I'm still missing a lot of objects needed to run the patch. @whale-av suggested using the help browser to get the right library- does anyone know what library/-ies I need to get these objects?

expr, expr~, fexpr~ version 0.4 under GNU General Public License
list-extend
... couldn't create
list-minmax
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
pink~
... couldn't create
pmenu v0.31 by tof
getdir
... couldn't create
splitfilename .
... couldn't create
splitfilename /
... couldn't create
splitfilename .
... couldn't create
splitfilename /
... couldn't create
getdir
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
midiparse
... couldn't create
list-extend
... couldn't create
list-dripslow
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
once
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux 1 2 3 4
... couldn't create
list-extend
... couldn't create
list-delete
... couldn't create
list-find
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
list-nth
... couldn't create
l
... couldn't create
mux 1 2
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
list-sort
... couldn't create
mux 1 2
... couldn't create
midiin: windows: not supported
tanh~
... couldn't create
l2s -
... couldn't create
time
... couldn't create
date
... couldn't create
getdir
... couldn't create
z~ 64
... couldn't create
z~ 64
... couldn't create

MouseState
... couldn't create
l2s
... couldn't create
list-idx
... couldn't create
list-delete 0 1
... couldn't create
deny 0
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
list-idx
... couldn't create
list-delete 0 1
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux 0 1 2
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
list-drip
... couldn't create
colorpanel
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
demux
... couldn't create
pmenu: 'default' is not an available option.
signal outlet connect to nonsignal inlet (ignored)
signal outlet connect to nonsignal inlet (ignored)
signal outlet connect to nonsignal inlet (ignored)

That's quite a long list. You're definitely missing "list-abs", and probably "zexy" (can't remember by heart now. Try these and come back, but maybe shorten your list as copying/pasting produces lots of things multiple times (there's a bunch of "demux ...couldn't create" messages in your post).

@s-elliot-perez Did you install or use the zip "portable"...?
You will need to open the Pd.exe (or Pd.darwin or whatever the executable is) for extended (in the bin folder) and then use its menu... open.. to open the miniwoog.
Extended has all those missing objects, but if you double-click miniwoog.pd it has probably opened in your vanilla installation.
David.