Hey all,
I am still pretty new to PD, and I have been slowly building some pieces for a serge like synth. I had some help on here a while back making a simple ASD
( I'm working in PD vanilla on a newer mac ). When I run this ( attached below) ASD I get these continued messages in the PD window:

$1: argument number out of range
$1: argument number out of range

I am hoping someone out there in PD land could take a look and let me know why these error messages are showing up ? Also feel free to suggest a better way to make this simple ASD.

JJR_ASD_2024_UPDATE_1.pd

@WEIRD1 said:

feel free to suggest

EDIT: better [del 200] to prevent getting stuck in instant invinite loops

@WEIRD1 I am sure that @lacuna has solved your problem.
When you see that message it means that an object is receiving too many message parts, or the wrong message...... containing symbols instead of floats for example.
So if you send [1 2 3( into [pack f f] you will see the error.

In the console you should be able to right-click the error and it will highlight the object that is complaining in blue. That doesn't always work, but most of the time it does.
I don't think that it is coming from your asdr though..... it looks ok.
David.

thanks so much for the help !!

@lacuna said:

EDIT: better [del 200] to prevent getting stuck in instant invinite loops

for some reason when I apply a long attack and very short S & D to the patch you showed above ( at least I think I created it correctly) it is very quite. This is not the case with my original. Here is an example of what gives me a very quite signal that doesn't sound like the attack is rising fully open ( from 0 -1).

@WEIRD1
Forgot to sum attack and hold-times, resulting in total delay for sustain-stage to start.

vline messages are
"go to 1 in A ms, wait for A+H ms then go to 0 in R ms"

@WEIRD1

Oh my sorry! Loop-delay fixed: